• Please try to select the correct prefix when making a new thread in this folder.

    Discuss is for general discussions of a financial company or issues related to companies.

    Info is for things like "Has anyone heard of Company X?" or "Is Company X legit or not?"

    Compare is for things like "Which of these 2 (or more) companies is best?"

    Searching is for things like "Help me pick a broker" or "What's the best VPS out there for trading?"

    Problem is for reporting an issue with a company. Please don't just scream "CompanyX is a scam!" It is much more useful to say "I can't withdraw my money from Company X" or "Company Y is not honoring their refund guarantee" in the subject line.
    Keep Problem discussions civil and lay out the facts of your case. Your goal should be to get your problem resolved or reported to the regulators, not to see how many insults you can put into the thread.

    More info coming soon.

Problem Cash Adjustment PNL in Vantage stole me -3531.79 dollars.

I am having an issue with a company

Azrael.2024

Recruit
Messages
5
Kind regards.

I am writing to inform you of the incredible scam by the Vantage broker.

I registered with the Vantage broker and a girl contacted me who would be my account manager. She was always excellent and there are no complaints about her services. I explained to her about a strategy model that I wanted to implement by hedging between 2 brokers, it turns out that for that I would need the tax-free swap account.

She very kindly presented my project to several leaders of the broker who required a minimum deposit among my referrals of 50 thousand dollars to provide me with this Swap Free account service. I agreed and contacted several potential friends who have a lot of money and they supported me with the project by creating their accounts and giving me access so that I could manage all the money.

Before starting, we had agreed that every month I was going to close with more deposits than withdrawals, keeping us above 45 thousand dollars. We also agreed that I was going to make withdrawals during the month to have capital and cover with the other broker. , all this was in advance and previously notified to the broker.

During the beginning the rules began to change and they no longer wanted me to make withdrawals at their broker because this affected them, which okay I understood perfectly, so I tried to deal with the situation with a withdrawal of 8 thousand and something that had done. I also decided to add another friend to the project who, thank God, was not able to invest since he was planning to invest 1 million dollars.

I made a first operation in account No. 510469977 in the name of Rubén Puente Lopez, for which he had no coverage since Rubén never had his account approved at the other broker due to his Spanish nationality, this account obtained a profit of 1895.91 dollars which were canceled with a “Cash Adjustment PNL”.

In the account of Luisa Gamarra & Ivan Cereijido Lopez, I did cover with the other broker since I understood that I had an agreement with Vantage since I myself notified them of my strategy and they agreed.

It happens that the risk department detected Luisa Gamarra's account as suspicious activity due to the coverage and therefore they made the decision to cancel Vantage's profits, profits that had been lost in the other broker, which represents lost capital for me with a total -1635.88 dollars.

Then they told me that this was only with Luisa Gamarra's account and that the other accounts were fine, but that if I continued with the project it had to be on the condition that I always lost in Vantage and the other broker won. This is when I explain to the broker that this is something that I do not control that could be won or lost in any broker, so since I was not going to be able to meet this condition, I chose to cancel the entire project and request the withdrawal of all the capital since I was the one who managed the accounts of my acquaintances.

Here they prohibited me from withdrawing from Rubén's account to cancel all the profits and let me leave with nothing, here I demand that the broker present the alleged evidence that there was some infraction in account No. 510469977 in the name of Rubén Puente Lopez because With this account I was not able to start the project as such and the profits obtained there were without any coverage. So the broker presented evidence to commit this theft that they did.

With the account of Ivan Cereijido Lopez, because this account was in loss with -784.45, here I made a demand that if this account had also violated their rules, then the ideal would be for them to return that capital in negative and cancel the orders as they did. before with Luisa's account. Well, the law does not apply here, because that law is only applied in their favor.

Regarding the money, I now have to work for more than 1 year to replace it with my acquaintances who had decided to support me and provided me with said capital. This is somewhat unfair because before starting I notified the broker of my strategy and they gave me their approval. In total, the stolen money is 3531.79 dollars.
 

Attachments

  • Luisa Gamarra 2.jpeg
    Luisa Gamarra 2.jpeg
    40.5 KB · Views: 36
  • Luisa Gamarra.jpeg
    Luisa Gamarra.jpeg
    70.9 KB · Views: 32
  • Ruben Lopez Puente (2).jpeg
    Ruben Lopez Puente (2).jpeg
    64.5 KB · Views: 33
  • Ruben Lopez Puente.jpeg
    Ruben Lopez Puente.jpeg
    43.7 KB · Views: 29
  • Ivan Cereijido Lopez.jpeg
    Ivan Cereijido Lopez.jpeg
    42.6 KB · Views: 29
Kind regards.

I am writing to inform you of the incredible scam by the Vantage broker.

I registered with the Vantage broker and a girl contacted me who would be my account manager. She was always excellent and there are no complaints about her services. I explained to her about a strategy model that I wanted to implement by hedging between 2 brokers, it turns out that for that I would need the tax-free swap account.

She very kindly presented my project to several leaders of the broker who required a minimum deposit among my referrals of 50 thousand dollars to provide me with this Swap Free account service. I agreed and contacted several potential friends who have a lot of money and they supported me with the project by creating their accounts and giving me access so that I could manage all the money.

Before starting, we had agreed that every month I was going to close with more deposits than withdrawals, keeping us above 45 thousand dollars. We also agreed that I was going to make withdrawals during the month to have capital and cover with the other broker. , all this was in advance and previously notified to the broker.

During the beginning the rules began to change and they no longer wanted me to make withdrawals at their broker because this affected them, which okay I understood perfectly, so I tried to deal with the situation with a withdrawal of 8 thousand and something that had done. I also decided to add another friend to the project who, thank God, was not able to invest since he was planning to invest 1 million dollars.

I made a first operation in account No. 510469977 in the name of Rubén Puente Lopez, for which he had no coverage since Rubén never had his account approved at the other broker due to his Spanish nationality, this account obtained a profit of 1895.91 dollars which were canceled with a “Cash Adjustment PNL”.

In the account of Luisa Gamarra & Ivan Cereijido Lopez, I did cover with the other broker since I understood that I had an agreement with Vantage since I myself notified them of my strategy and they agreed.

It happens that the risk department detected Luisa Gamarra's account as suspicious activity due to the coverage and therefore they made the decision to cancel Vantage's profits, profits that had been lost in the other broker, which represents lost capital for me with a total -1635.88 dollars.

Then they told me that this was only with Luisa Gamarra's account and that the other accounts were fine, but that if I continued with the project it had to be on the condition that I always lost in Vantage and the other broker won. This is when I explain to the broker that this is something that I do not control that could be won or lost in any broker, so since I was not going to be able to meet this condition, I chose to cancel the entire project and request the withdrawal of all the capital since I was the one who managed the accounts of my acquaintances.

Here they prohibited me from withdrawing from Rubén's account to cancel all the profits and let me leave with nothing, here I demand that the broker present the alleged evidence that there was some infraction in account No. 510469977 in the name of Rubén Puente Lopez because With this account I was not able to start the project as such and the profits obtained there were without any coverage. So the broker presented evidence to commit this theft that they did.

With the account of Ivan Cereijido Lopez, because this account was in loss with -784.45, here I made a demand that if this account had also violated their rules, then the ideal would be for them to return that capital in negative and cancel the orders as they did. before with Luisa's account. Well, the law does not apply here, because that law is only applied in their favor.

Regarding the money, I now have to work for more than 1 year to replace it with my acquaintances who had decided to support me and provided me with said capital. This is somewhat unfair because before starting I notified the broker of my strategy and they gave me their approval. In total, the stolen money is 3531.79 dollars.
Check out the resolved thread here https://www.forexpeacearmy.com/comm...its-of-34895-20-and-4000-deposit.80722/page-2

If you didn't find anything useful there, message me back so I can suggest more steps to divert their attention to your issue
 
Thanks, I just sent an email with copy to all those regulators.....Also I went into the website of FCA to contact them and report the broker.

I hope recover the money stolen, thanks a lot.
 

Attachments

  • 1721992636595.png
    1721992636595.png
    288.6 KB · Views: 27
Thanks, I just sent an email with copy to all those regulators.....Also I went into the website of FCA to contact them and report the broker.

I hope recover the money stolen, thanks a lot.
You are most welcome and keep us updated.
 
Gracias, acabo de enviar un correo electrónico con copia a todos esos reguladores... También ingresé al sitio web de la FCA para comunicarme con ellos y denunciar al corredor.

Espero recuperar el dinero robado, muchas gracias.
¿Es la FCA del Reino Unido? (Vantage UK)

Tu operativa no tiene sentido, salvo para arbitraje

Vantage es un bróker australiano, no creo que haga falta decir más, suelen
tener 0 spreads, pero en todo el libro son 8 contratos y cuando se acercan desaparecen.

Tu bróker puede liquidarte las cuentas sin mas, solo necesita preparar
su sistema para localizar tus paradas y/o coberturas

Además operas con capital de terceros, lo que se tendría que aumentar la seguridad.
 
¿Es la FCA del Reino Unido? (Vantage UK)

Tu operativa no tiene sentido, salvo para arbitraje

Vantage es un bróker australiano, no creo que haga falta decir más, suelen
tener 0 spreads, pero en todo el libro son 8 contratos y cuando se acercan desaparecen.

Tu bróker puede liquidarte las cuentas sin mas, solo necesita preparar
su sistema para localizar tus paradas y/o coberturas

Además operas con capital de terceros, lo que se tendría que aumentar la seguridad.
Yo estaba haciendo arbitraje y gana el Swap. El tema es que desde antes de iniciar hable claro con el broker a través de mi Gerente de cuentas y ella pasó la información y hasta me facilitaron las cuentas SWAP-FREE sin fees, estas cuentas no se las dan a cualquier persona, me las dieron con la condición de que invierta 50 mil dolares y que mensualmente debía cerrar por encima de esa cantidad. Entonces si todo fue con un previo acuerdo, el broker no debía de robarme el dinero de esa manera.
 
Abrir una cuenta con 50K en un bróker CFD? ( por si fuera poco, Australiano)

Los CFDs tendrían que estar prohibidos, es una estafa legalizada, no hagas coberturas y cuidado
con los stop, mejor dicho, no abras mas operaciones, guarda los extractos
Financial Ombudsman Service, aquí es donde tienes que presentar tu reclamación, si tienes por escrito
los acuerdos, no tendrás problema, tardaras un año seguramente, puedes presentar la queja en
la FCA, el regulador no te va a solucionar nada.

Suponiendo que la cuenta este bajo FCA UK, si es otra jurisdicción da el dinero por perdido

T&C haremos con tu cuenta lo que nos parezca, haremos los cambios que queramos sin
previo aviso, tendremos los spreads que queramos, las cotizaciones que nos parezca etc.etc

Los futuros también tienen swap y están centralizados, no te puedes fiar de nadie que trabaje en
un CFD bróker, solo buscan tu dinero.
 
Podías hacer lo mismo con un broker en Chipre acaba de cerrar, no era necesario
abrir dos cuentas.

Abres una cuenta para cobrar el swap en xxz un día xxz te abre el spread hasta el
infinito y te liquida la cuenta, adiós swap, como mínimo tendrían que ser cuentas
con spread fijo, en todo caso cinco minutos antes de pasar el swap te lo cambian
en vez de pagarte te cobran todo lo que tienes en la cuenta (bróker Uk. FCA).

Ten en cuenta que los bróker CFD son negocios creados para estafar al cliente,
cuando se crea el bróker, crean una sociedad para ejecutar las ordenes que les
interesan, si tu ganas ellos pierden.
 
Podías hacer lo mismo con un broker en Chipre acaba de cerrar, no era necesario
abrir dos cuentas.

Abres una cuenta para cobrar el swap en xxz un día xxz te abre el spread hasta el
infinito y te liquida la cuenta, adiós swap, como mínimo tendrían que ser cuentas
con spread fijo, en todo caso cinco minutos antes de pasar el swap te lo cambian
en vez de pagarte te cobran todo lo que tienes en la cuenta (bróker Uk. FCA).

Ten en cuenta que los bróker CFD son negocios creados para estafar al cliente,
cuando se crea el bróker, crean una sociedad para ejecutar las ordenes que les
interesan, si tu ganas ellos pierden.
Gracias por la información.
 
You are most welcome and keep us updated.
They said my manager would contact to me and she did it but for talking about the same and no give me the solution to return the money they stole.
 

Attachments

  • 1722946119392.png
    1722946119392.png
    180.9 KB · Views: 19
  • 1722946147896.png
    1722946147896.png
    179.7 KB · Views: 17
Back
Top