1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

How to examine a broker?

Discussion in 'Forex Trading Systems and Strategies' started by oleg2009, Sep 24, 2009.

  1. oleg2009

    oleg2009 Recruit

    Feb 20, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Successful use of scalping is directly depending on your broker. Experienced traders choose brokers very carefully with consideration of many factors.

    The first factor, is the spread on the traded currency pair . Most of the brokers give the information about spreads on traded currencies on their websites, but I would recommend to check the spread before you start the trade. I would check the spread on a real account ( you have to open real account, but you can quickly close it and therefore check how quickly you can withdraw money). For a spread checking I would recommend the advisor developed by BJF Trading Group Inc. You can download it here: FX Trading | FX FORUM • View topic - Free Metatrader Expert Advisors for free.

    Also, if your broker is ECN, check all the commissions in order to make sure that a broker won’t “eat” all your profit.

    Than I recommend to check the execution speed. In order to do this you have to place your advisor to trade with minimum lot and estimate the time interval between the starting time of sending order and it’s ending time. Go to the folder of log files C:\Program Files \metaTrader\logs\ and look on the log file.

    Example :
    00:56:26 '1003718': order sell market 0.20 USDJPY sl: 0.000 tp: 0.000
    00:56:27 '1003718': request was accepted by server
    00:56:27 '1003718': request in process
    00:56:27 '1003718': order was opened : #1635944 sell 0.20 USDJPY at 91.180 sl: 0.000 tp: 0.000

    We can see that advisor made it’s request for opening 00:56:26 and order was opened at 00:56:27 – good work.

    You have to also analyze all the teaks around particular order. It will help you to discover manual intervention. Broker can “throw” quotation in the stream of quotations in order to beat your “stoploss” or to give you maximum worst price. That’s why exploring of teaks will make everything clear. Analyze 10-20 orders.

    In the future, when you will pick a broker and start the state, I would recommend you to analyze every order. On the website BJF Trading Group Inc. (section Tools) , you can find an instrument AuditTool, that will help you a lot in analyzing orders. And an instrument was created from the will of brokers’ company and was tested by chief dealer.

    So analyzing of spreads ,speed and teaks around a order, will give you the full understanding of your broker. I recommend Micro, Mini, Standard & ECN/STP forex broker - Currency forex trading online – this is Canadian partner FXOPEN picked by me for the scalping. The only disadvantage of it is that the broker is not registered in NFA, even though most of USA brokers transfer their clients to other jurisdictions to escape NFA regulation.
  2. Raimundas

    Raimundas Corporal

    Sep 29, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Tool to examine quality of execution

    A few months ago I wrote for myself tool to examine quality of execution (see attached file). It works by principle described by oleg2009. You can select as many log-files as You want and then the program generates "Result.csv" file. Values "AvgDelayToOpen" and "AvgDelayToClose" are calculated separate for the every *.log file.

    Attached Files:

Share This Page