Sive Morten
Special Consultant to the FPA
- Messages
- 18,735
Fundamentals
(Reuters) - Gold jumped on Friday as the dollar and U.S. stocks fell on an ABC news report that former national security adviser Michael Flynn was prepared to tell investigators that Donald Trump directed him to make contact with Russians during last year's presidential election campaign.
Shares on Wall Street fell immediately after the report. Investors feared the political news could affect whether the Senate will pass a tax bill backed by Trump.
Within moments, however, gold came off its highs and U.S. stocks bounced off lows. Michael Matousek, head trader at U.S. Global Investors in San Antonio, noted that U.S. Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell said there were enough votes to pass the tax bill in that chamber.
The report about Flynn "was a good catalyst for people who were anticipating buying gold. It sparked the fear trade," Matousek said. Reuters has not verified the ABC News report, which cited a Flynn confidant.
Spot gold was up 0.3 percent at $1,278.01 an ounce by 1:39 p.m. EST (1839 GMT), after peaking to $1,289.50. The yellow metal was poised to end the week 0.8 percent lower. U.S. gold futures for February delivery settled up $5.60, or 0.4 percent, at $1,282.3 per ounce.
"Tax reform would be negative for gold," said Commerzbank analyst Carsten Fritsch, "because this will lead to higher inflation and more Fed rate hikes." He said the recent weakness in gold could be attributed to
an ongoing rally in global equity markets, boosted by "economic optimism and hopes regarding tax reform".
U.S. stocks this week hit record highs on bets that U.S. tax reforms would go through. On Thursday, gold fell 0.7 percent to touch its lowest since Nov. 6 at $1,270.11. A lack of clear drivers has kept gold between $1,265 and $1,300 an ounce throughout November, its narrowest monthly range in 12 years.
Separately, federal prosecutors said Flynn pleaded guilty to lying to the Federal Bureau of Investigation and also admitted to speaking with a top member of the Trump transition team regarding his communications with Russia's ambassador to the United States.
COT Report
So, now we know that Senate approves tax reform. On gold sentiment charts information looks blur. On CFTC report data we see that traders have closed shorts and gold net long position has increased. At the same time, overall net position stands at record highs and gold has limited upside potential. Mostly all speculators stand long. But, as rule, right at these moments market turns in opposite direction.
Second, on SPDR fund we see that storages have increased slightly while price has dropped. Although average range of fluctuations as SPDR data as gold prices now looks mostly as just noise - price usually stands one step ahead of SPDR - just check historical part of the picture. Whether this Senate's decision will bring collapse for gold?
Here is what we've read above, in comments:
"Tax reform would be negative for gold," said Commerzbank analyst Carsten Fritsch, "because this will lead to higher inflation and more Fed rate hikes." He said the recent weakness in gold could be attributed to
an ongoing rally in global equity markets, boosted by "economic optimism and hopes regarding tax reform".
The problem here is that recent data stands just for 28th of November, when gold showed upside triangle breakout on daily chart... So, this data could not reflect all reality.
Thus, it seems that sentiment analysis points just on possible downside action because gold stands near extreme levels of net long position. But we do not know how recent events will impact on sentiment. All that we have is just comments from Commerzbank trader.
Technical
Monthly
Monthly chart barely was impact by recent activity. Mostly our analysis here stands the same and we really have some fears on gold market perspectives, especially in the light of approved tax reform.
Recent events, guys, make us take critical look at action on gold market. Key markets show hints on dollar strength that could last for 6-8 months. As we coming closer to 2018 and December Fed meeting, as stronger pressure of anticipating of dollar strength becomes.
Thus, last time we've shown long-term charts on 10-year Notes, Dollar Index. They are suggest strong growth of US Interest rates that will be supportive for dollar, but deadly for gold market. Currently we see temporal relief but we still treat it as preparation for reversal in favor of USD.
And now perspectives of upside action do not look as promising as it was 2-3 months ago.
Currently gold has formed "222" Sell pattern on monthly chart. When price has started up from 1050 lows - long-term bear trend line has been broken and re-tested later. But after that upside action has slowed significantly. Besides, this upside action has taken the shape of AB-CD pattern, that is typical for retracement.
This makes us doubt on upside continuation here and we suspect that this AB-CD action of "222" pattern mostly should be treated as retracement after drop out from 1380 area rather than new upside leg.
September month has shown reversal shape and if it would have closed slightly lower, we could call it as "reversal candle".
October doesn't bring a lot of new inputs as trading range is rather small and mostly as September as October still stand in August range. November stands even smaller inside October range. this nested action indicates market's contraction and sooner or later will lead to fast breakout in one or other direction.
Besides, market stands at strong resistance area around 1330. It already has been tested once, but it is still valid. This is not just 3/8 major monthly Fib level. This is also Yearly Pivot Resistance 1.
Year is coming to an end and the fact that upside action was stopped by YPR1 tells that 2017 upside price action mostly a retracement of long-term bear trend.
Yes, we have bullish scenario as well. Next major target will stand around 50% Fib level and Agreement, as it coincides with upside AB=CD objective point as well. Market could take the shape of butterfly to get there, if our "222" pattern will fail. 1.27 extension also stands in the same area. But to keep this scenario valid price should not drop too deep. If gold will break 1205 lows, it will suggest deeper downside continuation and put butterfly and any upside continuation under question.
Right now we've got something, the new feature. It has not been totally formed yet, but it could appear. This is bullish grabber on monthly chart as MACDP line already has been tested. To be honest guys, I have real doubts on its count, as there are 3 weeks of action till the end of December and recent drop was really strong on gold market.
If miracle still will happen - this grabber could turn all situation from top to bottom.
Weekly
Here trend still stands bearish. Market stands in contraction phase as most recent swing is smaller than preceding one. In this kind of action price usually keeps valid opposite scenarios, and our case is not at exception.
If we will take careful look at the chart - we will see that here are possible as butterfly "Buy", as multiple "222" patterns as butterfly "sell".
Gold here also has completed harmonic retracement, after minor bounce up it showed deep retracement, but kept lows valid, and now shows upside action.
As on GBP, here price stands also near strong support area and forms triangle on daily chart.Thus, our task here is the same - watch for patterns and try to find safe way to trade it.
At first glance it might seem that we have bullish dynamic pressure as trend has turned bearish in early September, but price has not dropped any more. I suspect that this is not quite correct, as market is supported by strong K-support area. And particular this area but not some hidden bullish power keeps gold on surface.
So, as now as before we do not see on weekly gold any good setup for trading. Large '222" sell pattern has reached already "at least" target @ 3/8 Fib level. So, it could push price lower, but this is not an obligation any more. Thus, odds of this event are significantly lower
Daily
On daily chart situation also looks more bearish rather bullish. Take a look - market has failed to stay above broken triangle. Line already has been broken but price was not able to continue move higher and take out of 1305 top.
Trend has turned bearish here, and failure upside breakout now has become a "bullish trap" by classical technical analysis. It significantly increases opposite direction breakout.
As 1305 top is still valid - hence, our potential downside butterfly is valid as well. Gold also has dropped below MPP and Friday attempt to return back has failed.
Thus, currently it is very difficult to find some reasons to go long here.
Intraday
Here we see classical bearish behavior. Speaking on large AB-CD pattern - market was not able even to reach 1.0 extension and stopped at 0.618 by completion minor ab-cd inside the channel.
At the end channel was broken down and gold has formed bearish reversal swing. In fact, minor ab-cd was completed in mid November and recently target has been just re-tested. Gold has shown inability to continue move higher and formed W&R of previous top. After that collapse has happened.
Final confirmation of bearish reversal will be on a moment of "C" point breakout and erasing of large AB-CD pattern.
As soon as channel was broken and reversal swing been formed - gold has shown 5/8 upside retracement on Flynn Russian probe soap opera. As it was a point event and rally is not based on some strong background - it should go as fast as it has come.
As a result we have "222" Sell pattern at re-testing of broken channel line:
May be tax reform approving will bring some surprises on Monday, but by pure technical view - market has done all preparations for downside extension.
Conclusion
On longer term perspective now more factors have appeared that indicate more pressure on gold due coming USD strength. Now long term perspectives look even more blur, especially with tax reform approving.
In shorter-term perspective technical picture mostly looks bearish, as gold has done all preparations for downside continuation with daily butterfly pattern.
The technical portion of Sive's analysis owes a great deal to Joe DiNapoli's methods, and uses a number of Joe's proprietary indicators. Please note that Sive's analysis is his own view of the market and is not endorsed by Joe DiNapoli or any related companies.
(Reuters) - Gold jumped on Friday as the dollar and U.S. stocks fell on an ABC news report that former national security adviser Michael Flynn was prepared to tell investigators that Donald Trump directed him to make contact with Russians during last year's presidential election campaign.
Shares on Wall Street fell immediately after the report. Investors feared the political news could affect whether the Senate will pass a tax bill backed by Trump.
Within moments, however, gold came off its highs and U.S. stocks bounced off lows. Michael Matousek, head trader at U.S. Global Investors in San Antonio, noted that U.S. Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell said there were enough votes to pass the tax bill in that chamber.
The report about Flynn "was a good catalyst for people who were anticipating buying gold. It sparked the fear trade," Matousek said. Reuters has not verified the ABC News report, which cited a Flynn confidant.
Spot gold was up 0.3 percent at $1,278.01 an ounce by 1:39 p.m. EST (1839 GMT), after peaking to $1,289.50. The yellow metal was poised to end the week 0.8 percent lower. U.S. gold futures for February delivery settled up $5.60, or 0.4 percent, at $1,282.3 per ounce.
"Tax reform would be negative for gold," said Commerzbank analyst Carsten Fritsch, "because this will lead to higher inflation and more Fed rate hikes." He said the recent weakness in gold could be attributed to
an ongoing rally in global equity markets, boosted by "economic optimism and hopes regarding tax reform".
U.S. stocks this week hit record highs on bets that U.S. tax reforms would go through. On Thursday, gold fell 0.7 percent to touch its lowest since Nov. 6 at $1,270.11. A lack of clear drivers has kept gold between $1,265 and $1,300 an ounce throughout November, its narrowest monthly range in 12 years.
Separately, federal prosecutors said Flynn pleaded guilty to lying to the Federal Bureau of Investigation and also admitted to speaking with a top member of the Trump transition team regarding his communications with Russia's ambassador to the United States.
COT Report
So, now we know that Senate approves tax reform. On gold sentiment charts information looks blur. On CFTC report data we see that traders have closed shorts and gold net long position has increased. At the same time, overall net position stands at record highs and gold has limited upside potential. Mostly all speculators stand long. But, as rule, right at these moments market turns in opposite direction.
Second, on SPDR fund we see that storages have increased slightly while price has dropped. Although average range of fluctuations as SPDR data as gold prices now looks mostly as just noise - price usually stands one step ahead of SPDR - just check historical part of the picture. Whether this Senate's decision will bring collapse for gold?
Here is what we've read above, in comments:
"Tax reform would be negative for gold," said Commerzbank analyst Carsten Fritsch, "because this will lead to higher inflation and more Fed rate hikes." He said the recent weakness in gold could be attributed to
an ongoing rally in global equity markets, boosted by "economic optimism and hopes regarding tax reform".
The problem here is that recent data stands just for 28th of November, when gold showed upside triangle breakout on daily chart... So, this data could not reflect all reality.
Thus, it seems that sentiment analysis points just on possible downside action because gold stands near extreme levels of net long position. But we do not know how recent events will impact on sentiment. All that we have is just comments from Commerzbank trader.
Technical
Monthly
Monthly chart barely was impact by recent activity. Mostly our analysis here stands the same and we really have some fears on gold market perspectives, especially in the light of approved tax reform.
Recent events, guys, make us take critical look at action on gold market. Key markets show hints on dollar strength that could last for 6-8 months. As we coming closer to 2018 and December Fed meeting, as stronger pressure of anticipating of dollar strength becomes.
Thus, last time we've shown long-term charts on 10-year Notes, Dollar Index. They are suggest strong growth of US Interest rates that will be supportive for dollar, but deadly for gold market. Currently we see temporal relief but we still treat it as preparation for reversal in favor of USD.
And now perspectives of upside action do not look as promising as it was 2-3 months ago.
Currently gold has formed "222" Sell pattern on monthly chart. When price has started up from 1050 lows - long-term bear trend line has been broken and re-tested later. But after that upside action has slowed significantly. Besides, this upside action has taken the shape of AB-CD pattern, that is typical for retracement.
This makes us doubt on upside continuation here and we suspect that this AB-CD action of "222" pattern mostly should be treated as retracement after drop out from 1380 area rather than new upside leg.
September month has shown reversal shape and if it would have closed slightly lower, we could call it as "reversal candle".
October doesn't bring a lot of new inputs as trading range is rather small and mostly as September as October still stand in August range. November stands even smaller inside October range. this nested action indicates market's contraction and sooner or later will lead to fast breakout in one or other direction.
Besides, market stands at strong resistance area around 1330. It already has been tested once, but it is still valid. This is not just 3/8 major monthly Fib level. This is also Yearly Pivot Resistance 1.
Year is coming to an end and the fact that upside action was stopped by YPR1 tells that 2017 upside price action mostly a retracement of long-term bear trend.
Yes, we have bullish scenario as well. Next major target will stand around 50% Fib level and Agreement, as it coincides with upside AB=CD objective point as well. Market could take the shape of butterfly to get there, if our "222" pattern will fail. 1.27 extension also stands in the same area. But to keep this scenario valid price should not drop too deep. If gold will break 1205 lows, it will suggest deeper downside continuation and put butterfly and any upside continuation under question.
Right now we've got something, the new feature. It has not been totally formed yet, but it could appear. This is bullish grabber on monthly chart as MACDP line already has been tested. To be honest guys, I have real doubts on its count, as there are 3 weeks of action till the end of December and recent drop was really strong on gold market.
If miracle still will happen - this grabber could turn all situation from top to bottom.
Weekly
Here trend still stands bearish. Market stands in contraction phase as most recent swing is smaller than preceding one. In this kind of action price usually keeps valid opposite scenarios, and our case is not at exception.
If we will take careful look at the chart - we will see that here are possible as butterfly "Buy", as multiple "222" patterns as butterfly "sell".
Gold here also has completed harmonic retracement, after minor bounce up it showed deep retracement, but kept lows valid, and now shows upside action.
As on GBP, here price stands also near strong support area and forms triangle on daily chart.Thus, our task here is the same - watch for patterns and try to find safe way to trade it.
At first glance it might seem that we have bullish dynamic pressure as trend has turned bearish in early September, but price has not dropped any more. I suspect that this is not quite correct, as market is supported by strong K-support area. And particular this area but not some hidden bullish power keeps gold on surface.
So, as now as before we do not see on weekly gold any good setup for trading. Large '222" sell pattern has reached already "at least" target @ 3/8 Fib level. So, it could push price lower, but this is not an obligation any more. Thus, odds of this event are significantly lower
Daily
On daily chart situation also looks more bearish rather bullish. Take a look - market has failed to stay above broken triangle. Line already has been broken but price was not able to continue move higher and take out of 1305 top.
Trend has turned bearish here, and failure upside breakout now has become a "bullish trap" by classical technical analysis. It significantly increases opposite direction breakout.
As 1305 top is still valid - hence, our potential downside butterfly is valid as well. Gold also has dropped below MPP and Friday attempt to return back has failed.
Thus, currently it is very difficult to find some reasons to go long here.
Intraday
Here we see classical bearish behavior. Speaking on large AB-CD pattern - market was not able even to reach 1.0 extension and stopped at 0.618 by completion minor ab-cd inside the channel.
At the end channel was broken down and gold has formed bearish reversal swing. In fact, minor ab-cd was completed in mid November and recently target has been just re-tested. Gold has shown inability to continue move higher and formed W&R of previous top. After that collapse has happened.
Final confirmation of bearish reversal will be on a moment of "C" point breakout and erasing of large AB-CD pattern.
As soon as channel was broken and reversal swing been formed - gold has shown 5/8 upside retracement on Flynn Russian probe soap opera. As it was a point event and rally is not based on some strong background - it should go as fast as it has come.
As a result we have "222" Sell pattern at re-testing of broken channel line:
May be tax reform approving will bring some surprises on Monday, but by pure technical view - market has done all preparations for downside extension.
Conclusion
On longer term perspective now more factors have appeared that indicate more pressure on gold due coming USD strength. Now long term perspectives look even more blur, especially with tax reform approving.
In shorter-term perspective technical picture mostly looks bearish, as gold has done all preparations for downside continuation with daily butterfly pattern.
The technical portion of Sive's analysis owes a great deal to Joe DiNapoli's methods, and uses a number of Joe's proprietary indicators. Please note that Sive's analysis is his own view of the market and is not endorsed by Joe DiNapoli or any related companies.