RahmanSL
Major
- Messages
- 2,940
As I have written to Angus in an email, I think we are not only not on the same page but even the same book!
Metaphor to my issue with ICM:
The cock died because it was struck & run-over by a vehicle while crossing the road.
I asked for proof of that event, and was instead given a lecture on the birth & death of the cock…..meaning the cock would eventually and inevitably die anywhere.
I/we all know that facts of life, but where is the proof for the premature death of that cock?....and this time they start on the evolution of life and even the enigma “which come first - chicken or egg?” question.
It’s as simple as to show me the squashed cock and the place where it got run-over. End of story!
===================================
Let me try to simplify my issue with ICM and hopefully this time it can be much clearer and easier for ICM to understand the crux of my issue….and perhaps someone here is much more able and can better phrase my issue for ICM to understand:
I want and need ICM to provide irrefutable proof that the spread did widen sufficiently to cause instant/immediate account wipe/stop-out that happened so fast (as claimed by ICM) that absolutely no margin-call warning, followed by sequential forced closure of largest to smallest losing positions could take place.
The date & time is for the following news release:
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - US Factory Orders (MoM) - Previous: -3.5% - Consensus: 0.2% - Actual: -0.7%
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - Can. Ivey Purchasing Managers Index - Previous: 42.60 - Consensus: - Actual: 50.80
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - Can. Ivey Purchasing Managers Index s.a - Previous: 45.40 - Consensus: 50.00 - Actual: 49.70
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - US FOMC Member Williams speech
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - Hungary Budget Balance - Previous: 53.80B - Consensus: - Actual: 256.90B
Then, since they are also most relevant to my issue with ICM, what was the spread for USD/CAD for the following news releases which, as can be clearly seen on the MT4 screenshot chart, were apparently more volatile and so should be more likely to cause instantaneous account stop/wipe-out (if any instantaneous account stop-out is to occur) before the next (as in above) news releases :
5-Mar-2015, 20:45 – ECB Interest Rate Decision - Previous: 0.05% - Consensus: 0.05% - Actual: 0.05%
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 – ECB Monetary Policy Statement & Press conference -
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 – US Nonfarm Productivity - Previous: 3.7% - Consensus: -2.3% - Actual: -2.2%
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 – US Unit Labor Costs - Previous: -2.3% - Consensus: 3.3% - Actual: 4.1%
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 - US Continuing Jobless Claims - Previous: 2.40M - Consensus: 2.40M - Actual: 2.42M
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 - US Initial Jobless Claims - Previous: 313.00K - Consensus: 295.00K - Actual: 320.00K
Since English is not my first language, perhaps I have been unable to explain my issues adequately & eloquently and so, if someone here is able to understand my real issue, please help me to rephrase or even to rewrite them so that ICM can finally understand my real issues and to address them as requested.
Metaphor to my issue with ICM:
The cock died because it was struck & run-over by a vehicle while crossing the road.
I asked for proof of that event, and was instead given a lecture on the birth & death of the cock…..meaning the cock would eventually and inevitably die anywhere.
I/we all know that facts of life, but where is the proof for the premature death of that cock?....and this time they start on the evolution of life and even the enigma “which come first - chicken or egg?” question.
It’s as simple as to show me the squashed cock and the place where it got run-over. End of story!
===================================
Let me try to simplify my issue with ICM and hopefully this time it can be much clearer and easier for ICM to understand the crux of my issue….and perhaps someone here is much more able and can better phrase my issue for ICM to understand:
I want and need ICM to provide irrefutable proof that the spread did widen sufficiently to cause instant/immediate account wipe/stop-out that happened so fast (as claimed by ICM) that absolutely no margin-call warning, followed by sequential forced closure of largest to smallest losing positions could take place.
The date & time is for the following news release:
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - US Factory Orders (MoM) - Previous: -3.5% - Consensus: 0.2% - Actual: -0.7%
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - Can. Ivey Purchasing Managers Index - Previous: 42.60 - Consensus: - Actual: 50.80
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - Can. Ivey Purchasing Managers Index s.a - Previous: 45.40 - Consensus: 50.00 - Actual: 49.70
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - US FOMC Member Williams speech
5-Mar-2015, 23:00 - Hungary Budget Balance - Previous: 53.80B - Consensus: - Actual: 256.90B
Then, since they are also most relevant to my issue with ICM, what was the spread for USD/CAD for the following news releases which, as can be clearly seen on the MT4 screenshot chart, were apparently more volatile and so should be more likely to cause instantaneous account stop/wipe-out (if any instantaneous account stop-out is to occur) before the next (as in above) news releases :
5-Mar-2015, 20:45 – ECB Interest Rate Decision - Previous: 0.05% - Consensus: 0.05% - Actual: 0.05%
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 – ECB Monetary Policy Statement & Press conference -
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 – US Nonfarm Productivity - Previous: 3.7% - Consensus: -2.3% - Actual: -2.2%
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 – US Unit Labor Costs - Previous: -2.3% - Consensus: 3.3% - Actual: 4.1%
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 - US Continuing Jobless Claims - Previous: 2.40M - Consensus: 2.40M - Actual: 2.42M
5-Mar-2015, 21:30 - US Initial Jobless Claims - Previous: 313.00K - Consensus: 295.00K - Actual: 320.00K
Since English is not my first language, perhaps I have been unable to explain my issues adequately & eloquently and so, if someone here is able to understand my real issue, please help me to rephrase or even to rewrite them so that ICM can finally understand my real issues and to address them as requested.