Hi, the most important part to me about MD is the broker. And then just all the normal things like recovery and also the % of 0.2 or 0.25. Some people do not agree with this but MD has so much intelligence and I don't think there is another EA that can adapt to the market conditions that well. So just trust it and leave it. It will do the rest. I am running it live on The Collective (a broker club) for 4 months now and I am in a very healthy profit. It made a few losses over this period as normal and I need to pay membership fees every month but it's still in very good profit. In parallel I am running demos and also test other brokers. I can say my best broker for MD is ATC. On everything I tried ATC does the best on a very constant basis. So I would recommend that. I have a profit of 48% on ATC over that past 8 weeks total. That is 21.6% per month. I think it is good since the commission on ATC is 80% of one lot you trade. In other words $8 per full lot of $10 or 80 cents per mini lot. Its sounds a lot and looks a lot but the way MD trades makes that look like nothing.
Megadroid does not have "inteligence", this is just you applying human attributes to a computer program. Megadroid is a well writen program that tests for a stable and wide enough range during select trading hours, and when it finds this it trades it accordingly. It does not adapt or change this proccess, it simply goes through a check list and when things line up it trades. Thats why it goes through such long periods without any trades, and why it trades more often on a commision based broker with low spreads.
It does have good trade management in that it quickly detects when a trade is not going according to plan, or when a trade has been open too long. All it does in responce is to change its internal profit target to 1 pip. Generally this is enough to get out of the trade without any loss. When this doesnt work it will ride the trade to a full stop out, anywhere from less than 50 pips to over 150 pips.
Never blindly trust in anything, question everything, test everything.
Do not be suprised when history repeats itself.
The Collective is a very small, very expensive, unregulated, boutique brokerage. That may, or may not, survive industy changes. It is of benefit to anyone who has enough capital and trades frequently enough to overcome their fees, or got in early enough to get better rates. As of now, I dont believe there are any accounts available, at least none that are affordable. To make this brokerage work for you, you need to trade large lot sizes and very frequently.
ATC seems good. They have very good pricing, their commision is listed as 0.40/lot, they are regulated with the NFA and CFTC, yet have no problems with the hedging and FIFO regulations, they have a $5K minimum deposit, they trade mini lots and mico's after the first 0.10, and claim to offer IRA accounts. Yet they havent responded in over a week. Neither demo account requests or direct e-mails have recieved any responce, which places them in quite a questionable catagory.
Last edited: