elang
If you want to be fair with what you want to show do not just show the demo account I used for educational purposes where I deliberately margined out but also the EA that I am showing how I trade my live accounts, Account 109726 where as of today it is $753.000 in equity or over 650% profit and let people make their own decisions.
The fact that you and others are not able to do what I do does not mean the system does not work. I can handle it and make it work because I know how it works and that is what you still lack of. Practice, learn how to do it properly like me and you will make money.
Nobody here said your system does not work. Martingale systems work fine, until there is a large scale move, where you get wiped out.
People regardless of what others post, will always make up their own decisions, so there is no need to ask me to "let people make their own decisions". Like i said before, i've been trading for some time now and have very good experience with Martingale systems, on the code/programming level as well as practically in a trading environment.
Don't make assumptions in saying that i can't do what you do, because i can, and i'm sure there are others who do so as well, however Martingales are Martingales and the bottom line is, when the price drops, so does your account and no matter what method of calculation or optimization you use, it is all dwarfed by the fact that lot multiplications are critical requirement in maintaining a profit stream with this method of trading.
In regards to other accounts; i had no idea there were any and i honestly went through the thread carefully several times, so i must have missed them, which is why i contacted you for further information in the first place.
So i'm going to say this once again. A Martingale based system will always fail at the end. It will make money as long the market ranges between the parameters that define the systems operational structure, but once this is violated your account goes to $0.00.
Do i believe there are ways to manage this and actually make money out of a martingale system ? Yes. Will you loose everything in the end anyway if you don't take profit ? Yes.
I've worked with Martingales that racked in over 10K+ Pips on a monthly basis, but the bottom line is, If your account to lot ratio is set in such a way that it can't handle drops and rallies of 300 - 1000 PIPs without correction you're already bankrupt.
I'm speaking from a very professional point of view WilliamA, don't get offended or insulted, i am definitely not attacking you, i just want people to understands the risks of what they are stepping in to.
Further more, i have to add; that if you're really intent on actually teaching people how to trade a system, you would not be busy, opening trading accounts and providing password for people to log in under the argument that "you want them to see it working for themselves", because the fact of the matter is, every experienced trader who has been present in the market and is a witness to the nature of online communities such as forums, couldn't care less who believes what he has to say AS LONG AS somebody believes, because his genuine motivation would be to help people learn to apply a technique and to them if a few learned it, on a personal level he would feel gratified. Opening accounts and asking people to invest in you clearly shows that your intentions, at least based on that is not to teach people something, but to provide informational bait for other benefits.
If you really claim you started this thread out of the good of your heart and because you sincerely want to help other traders achieve success in their lives, then do so in the most standard way and take your time to write a clear, concise, straight to the point, well structured, well presented Tutorial so more people can benefit from your knowledge.
This would be the best way to help more people. I am just as interested as the next person in line, but i have to admit, your initial presentation of a system as complex as yours, shows you didn't really intend on having people understand it fully, if after all the "i still don't understand it" cries on the forum you still haven't decided to present it fully and more professionally.
Conclusively... If you really want to help people, then just write a tutorial, or have someone help you write it. If you want to charge a price for it, do so, i'm sure many people like myself and others would be more than happy to pay for a 5 page tutorial which is clearly laid out, than have to read through broken up ideas all over a nearly 40 page thread and try and put all the pieces of the puzzle together in a tedious exercise of hair pulling puzzle solving.
I'd love to know more and if you want to help people, you'd know that your current presentation isn't the best way to help interested folks digest what you have to say.
If you disagree with me, then answer me these two simple questions;
DO YOU PREFER TO:
A: TEACH PEOPLE HOW TO TRADE (so they can do it on their own)
B: MANAGE THEIR ACCOUNTS (so you can make money out of it)
And then, look at the charts below one of which is based on a 100% return per month and answer this, why would you need to mange someones account if in 15 months averaging just 100% you would have 1 Billion dollars (1000 x 1 Mio.) and 500% as you're claiming would hit 1 Bio. in 7 months. In 9 months you would be the richest man in the world over Warren Buffet, in 13 months your monthly turn over would be greater than that of the entire FOREX market put together, hedge funds, banks, corporations, private traders etc, at over 200 Trio.
If you need start up capital, just teach people your system for a price; instead of doing what you're doing now and playing them around like a ping pong ball. There is no shame in it, this is business, do you feel ashamed when you go to a bank to ask for a business Loan ? - No, so why now ? (This is my assumption, it may not be a fact)
I'm being realistic, and before anyone says i don't believe that things like this are possible, i know they are, so don't try and attack me with the common "you're just ignorant" fiasco, because that's not the case here.
Best Regards.
Lang