Pepperstone IS A SCAM

Ed_Forex

Private, 1st Class
Messages
240
Regulator will investigate on this.... the good thing is money are GAINS... i've already withdrew everything.....so i can wait ENDLESS time... and fight them....

You mean withdrew deposit and the scammed are the profits?
 

alfexcy

Private
Messages
13
They cannot know what your EA is doing internally so they cannot prove what they claim. I suggest you push them to give you your profit back or to give you proof of their claims...
 

alexx71

Recruit
Messages
184
Why ECN/STP brokers lost money if they were not actually Market Makers?

Their whole system proved to be a big failure.

Even if a broker is an ECN in this case ( unique CHF case ) there was not liquidity in the system to close the trade. The FXCM case and the losses they had show well this issue. So in this UNIQUE case was not the fault of brokers ( that usually try to scam us ). This case took the failure of broker fully regulated as Alpari Uk and other so I think now even brokers are victim of the " operative system " where the matching engines where unable to match the correct price due to zero liquidity in the electronic system. So even the broker will have problems with their liquidity providers ( banks )... but again this is a case more unique than rare.
 

sgalizia

Private
Messages
20
Even if a broker is an ECN in this case ( unique CHF case ) there was not liquidity in the system to close the trade. The FXCM case and the losses they had show well this issue. So in this UNIQUE case was not the fault of brokers ( that usually try to scam us ). This case took the failure of broker fully regulated as Alpari Uk and other so I think now even brokers are victim of the " operative system " where the matching engines where unable to match the correct price due to zero liquidity in the electronic system. So even the broker will have problems with their liquidity providers ( banks )... but again this is a case more unique than rare.

Alexx, i don't agree a single word of what you say. I'm going to explain why:

1. How can a broker allow, if you read all the posts, to close traders 3 hours after the event?
2. Why the broker allowed to trades CHF without manage margin required since was so evident of the incoming event (SNB was buying a lot of currency, you can find on internet)
3. Explaing this: KPMG: Reviewing Alpari UK Trade Fills and Asking Customers to Cover Negative Balances (Alpari UK to ask client to cover negative balance WHY?)

And if you, again, read all my posts you can find Pepperstone talk about EA, price difference and so on...

So please BROKERS are never victims...
 

Ed_Forex

Private, 1st Class
Messages
240
Even if a broker is an ECN in this case ( unique CHF case ) there was not liquidity in the system to close the trade. The FXCM case and the losses they had show well this issue. So in this UNIQUE case was not the fault of brokers ( that usually try to scam us ). This case took the failure of broker fully regulated as Alpari Uk and other so I think now even brokers are victim of the " operative system " where the matching engines where unable to match the correct price due to zero liquidity in the electronic system. So even the broker will have problems with their liquidity providers ( banks )... but again this is a case more unique than rare.

posters who defend brokers can't stop amazing me. After confessing its the broker bad operating system, no match engines no correct price and so on, they say not broker fault, isn't that nonsense.

Clients don't care what happens between LP's broker system broken and whatever, clients can be responsible of that, full responsibility goes to brokers.

Like others you'll fail to explain how other ecn/stp brokers filled stops 1.20 to 1.1980 applying its contract policy while others failed to do the same.
 

sgalizia

Private
Messages
20
Alexx, i don't agree a single word of what you say. I'm going to explain why:

1. How can a broker allow, if you read all the posts, to close traders 3 hours after the event?
2. Why the broker allowed to trades CHF without manage margin required since was so evident of the incoming event (SNB was buying a lot of currency, you can find on internet)
3. Explaing this: KPMG: Reviewing Alpari UK Trade Fills and Asking Customers to Cover Negative Balances (Alpari UK to ask client to cover negative balance WHY?)

And if you, again, read all my posts you can find Pepperstone talk about EA, price difference and so on...

So please BROKERS are never victims...

I mean... if you, broker, as me to cover negative balance...you must give me profits..... behaviors MUST BE THE SAME
 
Top