Please try to select the correct prefix when making a new thread in this folder.
Discuss is for general discussions of a financial company or issues related to companies.
Info is for things like "Has anyone heard of Company X?" or "Is Company X legit or not?"
Compare is for things like "Which of these 2 (or more) companies is best?"
Searching is for things like "Help me pick a broker" or "What's the best VPS out there for trading?"
Problem is for reporting an issue with a company. Please don't just scream "CompanyX is a scam!" It is much more useful to say "I can't withdraw my money from Company X" or "Company Y is not honoring their refund guarantee" in the subject line.
Keep Problem discussions civil and lay out the facts of your case. Your goal should be to get your problem resolved or reported to the regulators, not to see how many insults you can put into the thread.
More info coming soon.
when they saw proof that i have not traded out side the market now they are moving to new argument that i have used EA in trading in all my trading (i do not use any kind of bull **** EA) in this trading every trade i made that was totally manual trades.Abdul
They are basically saying that all your trades were illegal because you were using some kind of EA that was doing NOTHING ELSE but arbitraging. Now, if you told us what EA you were using and if it had an outside feed, we d MAYBE get somewhere.
Is it possible your EA did nothing else than taking advantage of some flaw in their platform ?
They also say your buy and sell orders had a minus value which ( if I understand properly ) means you were buying something at a certain price and selling at a higher price not in a sequence but at the same time ( denying the spread ). The spread ( for them ) would be a plus value ( like 2 pips ); a minus value would mean you d turn the table on them and you re the one getting a spread. They also hint at something more sophisticated when they talk of " interrupting " and " manipulating " their feed. I am no programmer and I dont know what is doable or not...but programmers amaze us so often... Their problem could even be compounded by the fact that they d rather keep such fatal weakness in their platform as much a secret as possible making frank communication with the FPA problematic.
You ask why your friend could do scalping without any problem with them...but was he using the SAME EA ?
You ask a definition of arbitraging. A simplified definition is that it s a strategy that makes you CERTAIN to win a profit. When you do arbitraging, you are not a speculator anymore. Look the definition of " speculate ". You " speculate " only when the outcome is NOT CERTAIN but you make a rational prediction that may or may not come true.
Me, I dont know if you did or if you did not use such software: I only see that your broker is adamant that you did. They seem very firm in their conviction. Convinced as they are, you will have no other choice than submit the case to the regulators of the Irish Financial Authority and they will examine the arguments from both sides.
It s impossible to understand anything from your last post except that you say you did only manual trades. Then, you ll win your case easily.
Now:
1) Did you use their proprietary AvaTrader platform or their MT4 platform ?
2) If you used their Avatrader platform, did you use their API libraries to build your own trading system or trade in real time ( something they allow BTW ) ?
3) what does ActTrader have to do with the topic ?
4) Can we see some trading log ?
he point is AVAFX's platform has the tools to prevent outside market positions.
In many cases me and my friends got 'pending order' or 'pair is unavailable for trading right now'(or something like that) if price really was outside market. These warnings and pending orders went off in matter of milliseconds, that means their platform is very fast and capable of preventing such positions.
Excuses like 'outside market prices' are insulting to traders with even average knowledge in forex trading and I really don't know what kind of regulatory body is controlling them if they let happen such obvious theft of hard earned money which took months to make and with such idiotic excuses.
That kind of moronic excuse can be used on every trader no matter the style of trading. And what is most ironic, they announce upcoming news in their platform half or one hour prior to happening and then when you trade around news time which they themselves advised you to do, they cancel your trade. This is misleading at best, if not fraud and attempted theft.
They canceled all trades eve ones that happen a year ago(whole trades not just, so called, 'difference in price'). But they didn't do or warn about anything until withdrawal, they even called me and said I was doing great and if I want to invest more!? That means that as long as money you earned is with them, at their disposal to invest off course, these trades are OK but when I wanted to withdraw, they 'found' 'outside market trades' exactly(to the cent!!??) in amount of my withdrawal. WTF!?
Oh and I DON'T use EA, I was using their order boxes or straddle, for very few trades around news time. So if they say I was trading illegal positions and outside market, they are my crime partner because they provided me with tools to do such 'illegal acts' as they say, ironic isn't it?
AVAFX is SCAM, period!
ActTrader features
Where is trading system actually hosted?
The trading system is hosted at ActForex’s SAS-70 certified data center and ActForex handles all connectivity issues. All third party price and order feeds are routed through ActForex’s data center so licensees do not need their own servers or IT department.
Traders Now Have Access to Professional Interbank Trading Function
New York, NY, May 3, 2011 – (PR.com) – ActForex, the leading provider of independent retail trading platforms, is pleased to announce today the addition of Market Depth functionality to its already extremely versatile and intuitive ActTrader platform. Every tick on the platform is able to display market liquidity in real time with the whole spectrum of price/volume data, rather than a single rate per instrument.
“Market Depth information used to only be available to professional Forex traders on an interbank level and even now for retail traders, this important feature is offered by just a few firms,” commented ActForex CEO, Ilya Sorokin. “Traders can now trade with greater information and confidence due to this seldom-before-seen transparency.”
Best Bid/Best Offer rates are computed by the platform, which also calculates and displays volume-based pricing for any selected order volume. This data allows the trader to see the real execution rate for high volume trades before opening an order. The new Market Depth feature creates a clear visual representation of how markets change with news or after hours, how the spreads correlate to volumes, and when the market shifts to the bid or offer side. This powerful information is extremely valuable to anyone trading Forex in such an enormous and fast-changing market.
About ActForex, Inc:
ActForex, Inc. has been providing leading-edge trading technology solutions for a multitude of FCMs, Forex Brokers, Broker/Dealers, Introducing Brokers and Money Managers worldwide since 2000.
ActForex logo and ActTrader are trademarks, and ActForex is a registered trademark, of ActForex, Inc.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
it is not clear to me that they have only this answer to my all questions
my html code is off i have a complete log file saved as (ghafoor statement .htm) i don't know how to post it here .Abdul
Is there a trading log that we can see ?
For the delay ( slippage )....it looks like they changed their platform because of you and Dutchess and a few others LOL